Malmaison Edinburgh, Edinburgh

The hotel was in a convenient location, close to Michelin starred restaurants and with easy access to central Edinburgh. The rooms, although clean, showed signs of age. The service was friendly and professional, complementing the overall experience. However, the dining experience was inconsistent with a mix of good and disappointing aspects. The value for money was decent with some aspects needing improvement.

The hotel is located down near the Port of Leith, away from the hustle and bustle of Central Edinburgh. The rooms are decorated to a high standard with great facilities and a good choice for breakfast, offering a view of the harbour. However, the dining experience can be hit and miss with long waits and limited availability. The service, though, is top-notch, and the staff handle situations professionally. The location is brilliant, especially when the easterly winds are not blowing, despite being a bit tired looking and affected by roadworks. The price may be a concern for some due to the indulgent pastry prices and not ideal breakfast service.

My stay at the hotel was a mix of ups and downs. The room was spacious and had an amazing view, but the initial cold and the need for an extra heater that kept cutting out were inconvenient. The service was excellent and the staff were charming and helpful, but there were also encounters with some unfriendly employees. The location was ideal for my event and exploring the Leith shore area, despite being a bit away from the city center. The dining experience was mostly good, with some exceptions. Overall, a stay with both positive and negative aspects.

The hotel had a beautiful view of a brick wall from my room, which was spacious and clean, but I expected more for the money. The service was lovely and very helpful, especially as we were arriving late in the evening. The location was great, just a few yards from 2 Michelin-starred restaurants, and the breakfast was included but cooked options were extra. The dining experience was not as good as expected. The facilities were decent but could be improved.

The hotel had a great location, situated in a quiet corner with a nice view. However, the suite room was small, impractical, and not very clean. On the bright side, I enjoyed the coffee machine provided in the room and the attentive service at the brasserie.

The hotel is situated in a lovely quiet area, close to bars and restaurants, and offers on-site parking. The rooms are clean and a good size, but I faced issues with poor shower water pressure during peak times. The service was friendly, but there were some mistakes with the breakfast order. The location is convenient for some restaurants and the royal yacht Brittany, although road works made transportation challenging. The dining experience was a treat at Mimi's Bakehouse nearby. Overall, a comfortable stay with a few minor hiccups.

My stay at the hotel was a bit of a mixed bag. The rooms were large and well furnished, but unfortunately, they faced the wrong way, making them extremely hot with minimal airflow. The reception was average, and I found it uncomfortable due to the heat. Despite the cleaning service forgetting to visit one day and breakfast not being included, the location in Edinburgh was great.

The hotel and booking process were okay, but not worth the high price. The rooms need decoration, especially because they lack net curtains. The service was friendly, attentive, and finished our stay nicely. The location was good with bus services nearby, although road works made it difficult to get around. The dining was good, but disappointed that it couldn't be brought to the room. The cost was relatively high for the dining experience.

My stay at the hotel was a mix of highs and lows. The rooms were lovely, spacious, and very clean, providing great comfort during my stay. However, the dark decor wasn't quite to my taste, as it gave a slightly dim ambiance in the room. The service was top-notch, with the evening brass staff and reception team being exceptionally polite and helpful. The location was fabulous, offering easy access to the city center despite lacking a good view from my room. The dining experience was a bit hit-and-miss, with limited options that didn't fully cater to my preferences. Overall, a comfortable stay with some minor drawbacks.

The hotel rooms were very small, and considering the out-of-town location, I wouldn't book again. Unfortunately, the mornings started loudly due to an engineering company nearby. On the bright side, access to Premier Inns is available.